Original Air Date: March 25, 2009
Patricia Morris Buckley — Associate Staff Writer
Last night, judges were almost more amusing to watch than the singers. Paula got out a coloring book for Simon, noting his immaturity (tell me that joke wasn’t setup). Then Simon drew a crayon mustache on her that kept Allison Iraheta laughing so hard that the 16-year-old singer couldn’t hear the criticism they gave her (it was mostly good).